Murder Mystery Dinner in Pythian Castle: Springfield, Missouri

What better place to hold a murder mystery dinner than a haunted castle, especially as a prelude to a ghost tour? A murder mystery would certainly set the mood for the haunted tour that we would attend later that night. We approached the daunting limestone Pythian Castle just before dusk, walking up the stairs toward the massive wooden entrance doors.

Pythian Castle, Springfield Missouri, Murder Mystern DinnerInside the castle and in queue to check in for dinner, I took a quick look around the expansive entry hall and spied a suit of armor in the corner. A castle isn’t complete without a suit of armor.

Suite of armor, Pythian Castle, Springfield MissouriA guy wearing a bad wig assigned the roles we would play: I was Bossie Jo Bratley and Skip was Opie—with a speaking part. It turns out Wig Man was playing the part of Andy and would later play Barney. Okay, so much for setting a scary mood. This was going to be light-hearted fun.

Murder Mystery Dinner at the Pythian Castle, Springfield MOAudience participation at the Pythian Castle Murder Mystern Dinner, Springfield MOI’d been to a couple of murder-mystery dinners before, but none where every guest played a role. The play combined spoofed characters from the old Andy Griffith Show and Petticoat Junction sitcoms, as well as real-life celebrity names with a comical twist. During the pre-show cocktail mix-and-mingle time we were given tasks. I was to find Goober and Gomer, both eligible bachelors, since my mom was trying to get me and my fifteen sisters married off. Goober and Gomer were nowhere to be seen, although they ended up sitting at the table next to us during dinner.

Don’t miss a Midwest Wanderer post.  For a FREE subscription, enter your e-mail address in the Subscribe2 box to the left and click Subscribe.

The play took place between meal courses, which began with a salad and rolls. The entrée was served buffet style. According to the Pythian Castle web site, the meal varies but always consists of a chicken dish, vegetables and potatoes, with vegetarian options available upon request. We had chicken-fried chicken, mashed potatoes and fresh mixed vegetables. Dessert was an ooey-gooey rich chocolate cake, the consistency of a fudge brownie.

Salad course at Pythian Castle Murder Mystery Dinner, Springfield MODuring dessert we filled out slips of paper indicating who we suspected as the murderer. Of those who guessed correct (neither Skip nor me), a name was drawn for a prize.

The play was corny, yes, but the silliness was perfect for audience participation. Of the three murder mystery dinners I’ve been to, the one at Pythian castle was most entertaining.

Be sure to check out our new road trip blog, U.S. Long Cuts.

Pythian Castle holds a murder mystery dinner once a month, always on a Friday evening. Check the web site for the schedule or to make reservations.

What about the ghost tour? Now that was eerie. I’ll tell you about it in my next blog post.

Disclosure: My visit to Pythian Castle was hosted by the Springfield Missouri Convention and Visitors Bureau and Pythian Castle, but any opinions expressed in this post are my own. Photos by Skip Reed.

Other articles that may interest you:              

Farmers Market of the Ozarks: A Foodie’s Gold Mine

Branson, Missouri, Remains the Live Music Show Capital of the World

A Nostalgic Stay at the Rote 66 Rail haven Motel in Springfield, Missouri



2 thoughts on “Murder Mystery Dinner in Pythian Castle: Springfield, Missouri

  • April 9, 2015 at 1:49 pm

    I’ve always wanted to do a professional murder mystery dinner like this! Did one with friends a few years ago, but this looks awesome!

    • April 9, 2015 at 2:00 pm

      It was a lot of fun, John, and we doubled our evening entertainment with the ghost tour that followed.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *