Bill Humphries knew that more often than not women choose the place to eat when a couple dines out. So he wanted a lighter, airier atmosphere for his restaurant, an ambiance that would appeal to men and women alike. He felt that too many steakhouses are heavy with dark wood. The result is elegant richness in Eddie Merlot’s restaurant decor, much like the food they serve.
Last fall I had breakfast at Frank’s Diner in Kenosha, Wisconsin, and dined on Garbage. Recently I ate Garbage again, this time at Cindy’s Diner in Fort Wayne, Indiana. It’s hard to resist ordering a dish with such an unappetizing but fun name, especially when it’s the diner specialty.
The exact Garbage ingredients differ between the two diners, but the concept is the same. At Cindy’s Diner, Garbage is a combination of hash browns, eggs, cheese, onions and ham, all combined on the grill and cooked until golden brown.
Cindy’s Diner is a nostalgic trip back to the 1950s when these ready-made diners were all the rage. The diner cost in 1952 was $6,000. Over the years it was sold and moved a few times. The current owners purchased it in 1990, moved it to its downtown Fort Wayne location, restored it to its original condition, and renamed it. Owner John quipped, “I was working construction and bought it for my wife. Now she’s at home, and I’m here.”
The small diner seats only 15, on stools around the counter, so plan your timing accordingly. We went on a weekday for a late breakfast. Whether it was good timing or luck that our group of eight was able to be seated together, I’m not sure.
Cindy’s Diner is open Monday through Saturday from 6 a.m. to 2 p.m. and on Sunday from 7 a.m. to 2 p.m., serving breakfast and lunch. I suggest saving room for a donut, made on the premises.
Cindy’s Diner is due to be picked up off the foundation and moved once again, making way for a 15-story office building on the current site. So if you visit Fort Wayne and the diner no longer at 830 South Harrison, go one block north and one block west to Webster and Berry Streets. Be ready for a dose of nostalgia and a satisfying meal of Garbage.
Disclosure: My visit to Cindy’s Diner was hosted by Visit Fort Wayne, but any opinions expressed in this post are strictly those of the author.
Thank you for reading Midwest Wanderer. If you enjoyed this post and would like an e-mail notification when other posts are published, enter your e-mail address below and click Subscribe. Be sure to click the link when you get the e-mail asking you to confirm.
What to do when there are more restaurants to try than there are meal times? A progressive dinner is what we did one evening in Fort Wayne, with appetizers and cocktails at an Irish pub, salads and entrees at a local iconic steak house, and dessert at a chocolate shop.
We were greeted at our first stop, J K O’Donnell’s in downtown Fort Wayne, with Guinness and an Irish cocktail. I’m not much of a beer drinker, so one sip of the Guinness is all I had, but I drank every drop of the cocktail that combined Irish whiskey and Baileys.
J K O’Donnell’s prepares 98% of their food in-house, including the breadsticks, little fingers of golden crispness on the outside and tender on the inside. Fried pickles, becoming ubiquitous in pubs, were on the evening’s menu, as were Scotch eggs, something I’ve always wanted to try, hard boiled eggs coated in pork sausage, then breaded and deep-fried. A cholesterol feast but tasty.
Families are more than welcome at J K O’Donnell’s, but since Indiana law doesn’t allow children in a bar area, a separate room is available for families
Don Hall opened his first restaurant in 1946. Today the family owns a dozen restaurants in and near Fort Wayne, all unique, ranging from a drive-in to fine dining. The Old Gas House, in business since 1958, is exactly as the name implies—it’s in a 19th century gas plant. At this steak house we started with warm bread with a choice butters, one savory and one sweetened with honey, and salads. My favorite salad was the Spring Greens with strawberries, dried cherries, walnuts, and goat cheese, served with black currant vinaigrette.
Next came the entrees, including Herb Crusted Pork Tenderloin served with Dijon-caper cream, sautéed mushroom, and caramelized shallots, and Dan-O’s Ribeye Steak, blackened and served with mashed potatoes, fried onions, and Andouille hash.
In the summer you can dine outdoors, if you wish, on the banks of the St. Mary’s River.
Dessert was a chocolate tasting splurge at DeBrand Fine Chocolates, Fort Wayne’s own gourmet chocolate company, where they make all their own creative centers and pair them with fine dark, milk and white chocolate.
The dark chocolate truffle was delicious, but my favorites were the dark chocolates in the Connoisseur Collection, like the Mayan Gold, intense dark chocolate ganache encased in dark chocolate with a bit of edible gold leaf on top. Talk about rich! Another of my favorites was Rosemary, dark chocolate filled with a citrus blend and rosemary. The Espresso was decadent, too, dark chocolate filled with intense dark chocolate-espresso ganache. Do you see a pattern here? Yes, I love dark chocolate, and being spoiled with rich gourmet chocolates like DeBrand, I am becoming quite a chocolate snob.
Our chocolate tasting was at one of the DeBrand stores, but you can also see how the chocolates are made on a tour of the kitchens at the Auburn Park Drive location.
The progressive dinner was sponsored by Visit Fort Wayne, but it’s an idea that I may borrow. What a great way to spend an evening—sampling foods from several great places, creating your own “taste of” a city.
Disclosure: My visit to Fort Wayne was hosted by the Visit Fort Wayne, but any opinions expressed in this post are strictly those of the author.
Thank you for reading Midwest Wanderer. If you enjoyed this post and would like an e-mail notification when other posts are published, enter your e-mail address below and click Subscribe. Be sure to click the link when you get the e-mail asking you to confirm.
