We spent the early evening at a murder-mystery dinner in Pythian Castle’s ballroom. Now the mood changed, from light-hearted to eerie, on a 10 p.m. tour of the Pythian Castle. We were going to look for the ghosts that haunt the building.
Pythian Castle history
The Knights of Pythia fraternal organization built Pythian Castle in Springfield, Missouri, in 1913. The building served as an orphanage and a retirement home for organization members and their children. In 1942 the military took it over for use as a service club. It’s also rumored that German prisoners of war were kept in basement cells.
After the military abandoned the building, it sat vacant for years and fell into. Three times a local university turned down offers to take possession of the building, free of charge. The land the castle sat on was worth less than the cost to raze the building. It castle finally sold at auction for a mere $1300 and later was resold to the current owners, Tamara Finocchiaro and her mother. The women were specifically looking to purchase a castle.
Don’t miss a Midwest Wanderer post. For a FREE subscription, enter your e-mail address in the Subscribe2 box to the right and click Subscribe.
Through lots of hard physical labor the women have beautifully restored much of the building, and the work continues.
Ghosts in Pythian Castle
Ghost stories are abundant here. Some of the ghosts are children and some are adults. Our guide, Tim Piland, told us that the ghosts often make themselves known during these tours.
Tim began our tour in the ballroom with an overview of the castle’s history. He related his own experiences with the ghosts, starting on the night he was recruited to castle-sit while the owners were away. He led us through the kitchen, down narrow, steep cement steps to the dimly lit, dank basement, which we explored in three segments.
The first area was sectioned into several jail cells. This is where many people have captured orbs in photos they’ve taken. Skip set the camera to low-light, slow speed. He got some good photos of the cells, but no orbs.
As usual, I had to have my photo taken in jail. I admit I was creeped out by the one.
Our next stop was the “dungeon,” a smallish cement room, maybe twelve feet square, that the Pythians originally used as a root cellar. Other visitors have conducted EVP (electronic voice phenomenon) recordings here and have picked up voices. More on that later.
Was it a ghost?
Tim turned off all the lights and called out to the ghosts, identifying himself and asking questions of them, like “Is there a child with us tonight?” and “Is there a soldier?” Silence the entire time. No ghosts revealed themselves.
However, as we were walking out of the dungeon, Skip walked through a cold spot and the hair stood up on the back of his neck. There were no air ducts anywhere around. He’d felt that once before, when we were on a battlefield in Gettysburg on a 90 degree day.
Next we walked single-file down a narrow steam tunnel, only a few feet wide, another area where ghosts are sometimes known to hang out. Nothing.
We went up to the third floor for the remainder of the tour. In the theater, where in 1914 you could see a movie for a nickel, Tim played EVP recordings that had captured ghostly muffled voices in the past.
Our last tour stop was the boys’ dormitory, one of the rooms not yet renovated. Tim conveyed a fascinating story here about a young boy who lives in the castle and often makes himself known. A visiting medium had a very specific conversation with him in Tim’s presence mentioning facts the medium could not have known but Tim knew to be true.
If you take the Pythian Castle ghost tour
Whether or not you believe in ghosts, the tour is fascinating. Daytime ghost tours are conducted daily at 1 p.m. The schedule varies for the night tours led by Tim Piland, but they’re usually on Friday nights. History tours are also available several times daily. Check the Pythian Castle web site for schedules, rates and other details. Pythian Castle is located at 1451 E Pythian Street in Springfield Missouri.
We stayed at the Best Western Plus Coach House on this visit to Springfield. Find the best hotel deal in Springfield, compare prices, and read what other travelers have to say at TripAdvisor.
Disclosures: Our visit to Pythian Castle was hosted by the Springfield Missouri Convention and Visitors Bureau and Pythian Castle, but any opinions expressed in this post are my own.
This article contains an affiliate link. If you book a hotel room through the TripAdvisor link above, I will receive a small commission, at no additional cost to you.
Thank you for reading Midwest Wanderer. Don’t miss a post. Enter your e-mail address below and click Subscribe to be notified whenever I publish another post. Subscription is FREE. After subscribing, be sure to click the link when you get the e-mail asking you to confirm. – Connie
13 thoughts on “Looking for Ghosts in Pythian Castle”
Such a fun adventure – spooky!
Yes, it was fun, as long as I was with a crowd. It does get a little spooky.
I’ve never heard of Knights of Pythias, but the castle sure looks interesting, and I wouldn’t be surprised if there were real ghosts in there. Maybe that night they were just a little bit shy.
I had never heard of the Knights of Pythias before either, Jolanta. Apparently they’re still around and have existed for 150 years according to their web site.
What a fascinating place to visit! Putting on the list!
I recommend it, Renate. They offer a history tour, too, which would be interesting but not nearly as fun, I think, as the ghost tour. And you do get some of the history on the ghost tour, too.
Ghosts + castle… sounds like my kind of thing to do!
From what I understand, around Halloween another group goes in and turns the castle into a (fake) “haunted” place. I wouldn’t find that nearly as eerie as just hearing the real stories and having the tour leader trying to communicate with the ghosts. Whether anything happens or not, and whether you believe in it or not, doesn’t matter. It’s still spooky.
The midwest s one of the last frontiers for me in the US. This looks like a wonderful place to start exploring!
I’ve lived in the Midwest all of my life, Eileen, and I’m always amazed at the things to do here that I never new existed. There’s a whole lot more than corn and soybeans. LOL
it is the first time I heard about this castle and its story. I have to say that after reading your text and seeing your pictures, the place does look spooky. It seriously looks like one of those place were ghost shows are filmed.
Love a good scary story! Ghost tours are great though I have to admit I do avoid them when travelling alone because I get too scared aha!
I’ve never heard of the Kings of Pythias. This place looks like from a legend…