Following the Amish Country Heritage Trail Driving Tour

Last summer we headed to Elkhart County in northern Indiana to travel the world’s only quilt gardens driving tour. The quilt gardens are intertwined with the area’s Heritage Trail, so we essentially took two driving tours simultaneously. The drive takes you along city streets and country roads in both Elkhart and LaGrange Counties, passing through seven cities and towns, including Nappanee and Shipshewana, the heart of Amish Country.

Amish Buggy

A CD with the narrated Heritage Trail Driving Tour was waiting for us at our B&B, but you can get the free CD at the Elkhart County Visitor Center. If you’d prefer, you can download the MP3 files from the Elkhart County CVB web site to your smart phone or other device. While you’re at the visitor center, also pick up a Quilt Gardens Tour map.

The narration begins from the Elkhart County Visitor Center, but you can change to another CD track if you start from another location. We started the tour in Bristol, since we were staying at the Murphy Guest House in that town.

Murphy Guest House
Murphy Guest House

Following the Heritage Trail Driving Tour


The building that houses the Elkhart County Historical Museum was originally Indiana’s first consolidated school. Built in 1903, the school combined eight one-room schools. We didn’t get a chance to go inside the museum, since it was after hours when we started the Heritage Trail tour. We did, however, take a photo of the quilt garden in front of the museum.

Elkhart County Historical Museum

Down the road, and next to the B&B where we stayed, a marker commemorates the Underground Railroad and specifically, an 1847 incident. Three slave hunters from Kentucky broke into a home to try to capture a fugitive slave living in Bristol. The three men were convicted of causing a riot, and the fugitive slave fled. However, the Indiana Supreme Court later reversed the decision that found the men guilty based on an earlier U.S. Supreme Court ruling.

Underground Railroad Commemorative Marker

Continuing on, you’ll see the Bristol Opera House, built in 1897. The building is now home to the Elkhart Civic Theatre.

Bristol Opera House

Elkhart County’s oldest church, St. John of the Cross Episcopal Church, is also located in Bristol. This nationally registered historic landmark still functions as a church.

St John of the Cross Episcopal Church
St John of the Cross Episcopal Church

Our last stop in Bristol was the Bonneyville Mill County Park. The park is a beautiful recreational area. A highlight of the park is the restored Bonneyville Mill. During summer months you can take a self-guided tour of the grist mill, watch the mill in operation, and purchase milled flour. Unlike most grist mills we’ve seen, Bonneyville Mill uses a horizontal water wheel rather than a vertical water wheel.

Bonneyville Mill


Driving on to Middlebury, we stopped at the Krider World’s Fair Garden. Vernon Krider founded Krider Nurseries in 1896. He developed the first thornless rose and gained world-wide recognition with it. Krider was invited to design a garden for Chicago’s 1933 Century of Progress International Exposition. Following the exhibition, Krider brought the garden back to Middlebury—plants, waterfalls, and all. Those are the same gardens that exist today.

Kriders Worlds Fair Garden

Also in Middlebury is Das Dutchman Essenhaus, a huge complex that includes shops, an inn, conference center and an Amish-style restaurant, where you can order off the menu or choose a buffet or family-style meal. Unfortunately, when we passed Das Dutchman Essenhaus, we were still full from the big meal we had at the B&B that morning.

Just outside of town, we did stop at the Deutsch Kase Haus Cheese Factory, where we tasted and stocked up on cheese. My favorite was the hickory smoked cheddar.



Shipshewana has only 550 residents, but over a million visitors come to town each year. Folks mainly visit for the Amish attractions—dozens of small shops, buggy tours and restaurants. Another huge attraction is the 100-acre flea market with almost 900 booths. The flea market is open every Tuesday and Wednesday. Shipshewana traffic gets very congested on the flea market days. If you’re planning to go, get there early (it opens at 8 a.m.). We made the mistake of getting there in late morning. Traffic was so heavy, we gave up, since we still had a lot to cover that day. We’ll go back again sometime to experience the flea market.

Another Shipshewana attraction is Menno-Hof, a museum that traces Amish and Mennonite history from their immigration to America from Europe, all the way through to present day. We didn’t have time to visit, but it’s definitely on the list for our next trip to the area.



The next town on the Heritage Trail is Goshen, the Elkhart County seat. Streets that surround the town square are filled with small shops. The grand courthouse stands prominently in the square’s center. You may wonder, as we did, about the small building on the southwest corner of the square. During the Depression era, banks on three corners of the square were vulnerable to gangster robberies. The Goshen Police Department stationed sentries in the bunker to watch for gangster activity.

Downtown Goshen

Stop at the Old Bag Factory in Goshen if time allows. The 1890 complex first housed a soap company and later, a factory that produced cloth, mesh, and paper bags. The renovated building now is home to several artisan shops. After a light lunch at the Trolley Café, we browsed the shops, which include baked goods, pottery, quilts, second-hand musical instruments, and more.

Old Bag Factory


Back on the Heritage Trail, we headed to Nappanee, another Amish community.

Our first stop was the Coppes Commons. The building was originally the factory for Coppes Kitchen Cabinets, including the Dutch Kitchenet. The Dutch Kitchenet was an kitchen step-saver that included a sugar bin, flour sifter, meat scale, and food grinder, all in one. It also had a slide-out compartment for additional work space.  Today the Coppes Commons building is filled with vendors that sell Amish foods, antiques, and other goods. We were especially intrigued by Lera’s Rugs. Lera is an Amish woman who weaves rag rugs, blankets, and table runners as you watch. On the upper level of Coppes Commons is a museum with memorabilia from Coppes Kitchen Cabinets.

Next, we stopped at the Nappanee Welcome Center to check out some of the area history. Besides Amish memorabilia, you’ll find exhibits on successful cartoonists who called Nappanee home, including Bill Holman, best known for his comic strip, “Smokey Stover.” There is also a restored home inside the welcome center, furnished as it would have been in the early days.

Nappanee Welcome Center

A popular Nappanee attractions is Amish Acres. We didn’t stop there on this tour, except to take a couple of photos. However, we did spend a weekend there years ago. From what we could tell, it hasn’t changed much. The attraction includes a tour of an Amish farmstead, a restaurant that serves a family-style Threshers Dinner, and the Round Barn Theater. Seasonally, you can also watch artisan demonstrations, including broom making and quilting.

Amish Acres

Down the trail Heritage Trail a little way, you can do more shopping at the Dutch Village Market. Dutch Village Market is a 70,000 square foot marketplace that sells crafts, gift items, and antiques.


The highlight of small Wakarusa is the Wakarusa Dime Store, in business since 1907. The store specializes in candy, boasting over 450 kinds. Choices include nostalgic candies like Mary Janes and Necco Wafers. In 1969 then-owner Lou Wolfberg developed jumbo jelly beans, which were an instant hit. Jumbo jelly beans are still popular, selling at the rate of 75 tons every year.


The last—and largest—city that we explored on our Heritage Trail drive was Elkhart.

With my husband being the rail buff that he is, we had to stop at the National New York Central Railroad Museum. The museum preserves the rail heritage that was a big part of Elkhart. In fact, even today, the Norfolk Southern Railway’s Elkhart Yard is the largest railroad freight classification yard east of the Mississippi River. The museum includes renovated train cars, memorabilia, and extensive model railroad layouts.

National New York Central Railroad Museum

Continuing on, we spent a couple of hours exploring the 36-acre Wellfield Botanic Gardens. Wellfield is comprised of over 20 individual gardens. The English Cottage Garden, Waterfall Garden, Conversation Garden, and the Pergola Garden are just a few. Additional gardens are under construction. Water makes up over half the site, which has been beautifully integrated into the gardens. It’s hard to believe that at one time, the site, which is the same property from which the City of Elkhart pumps its drinking water, was an eyesore. Wellfield Botanic Gardens is a tremendously successful beautification project. If you enjoy gardens, it’s a must-see.

Wellfield Botanic Gardens

Downtown Elkhart

We also toured two of Elkhart’s historic homes: the Havilah Beardsley House and Ruthmere Mansion. The Havilah Beardsley House, built in 1848, was the first brick house built in Elkhart and is the oldest surviving residence. Dr. Havilah Beardsley founded Elkhart in 1830 when he purchased a one-square mile tract of land from Potawatomi Chief Pierre Moran for $1500. He and his children were influential in Elkhart’s early history.

Havilah Beardsley House
Havilah Beardsley House

One block east of the Havilah Beardsley House is the Ruthmere Mansion. Albert Beardsley, nephew of Elkhart’s founder, had Ruthmere Mansion built in 1908. Designed by architect E. Hill Turnock, the home was named for his only child, Ruth, who died in infancy. Albert Beardsley was one of Elkhart’s most prominent businessmen, and Ruthmere, lavishly decorated with hand-card mahogany woodwork, Tiffany glass and Rodin sculptures, reflects his success.

Photos courtesy Elkhart County, IN CVB

Take time to explore some of downtown Elkhart on foot. Perhaps take a stroll along the Riverwalk. We ate dinner on the patio at McCarthy’s on the Riverwalk. From where we sat, we could see across the river to Central Park. It happened to be at the height of the Pokemon GO craze. The park was filled with young people seemingly wandering aimlessly as they played. It was fun to watch as we relaxed over our shepherd’s pie and wine.

Elkhart Indiana

If you drive the Amish Country Heritage Trail

  • The trail takes you down a lot of country roads that you share with Amish buggies. The buggies are not required to move to the shoulder. Take it slow and wait until it’s safe to pass them. Do not honk your horn, as it may spook the horses.
  • Be respectful to the Amish you encounter. Most have religious objections to having their photograph taken.
  • The tour narration includes turn-by-turn directions for the Heritage Trail. It’s helpful, though, for your passenger to follow along with a map that you can pick up at the Elkhart County Visitor Center.
  • The narrator will also give you directions to optional key attractions that are a short way off the trail, including the RV Hall of Fame and Museum.
  • The length of time it takes to drive the 90-mile trail depends on how many stops you make. If you stop at every attraction, you could spend several days on the trail. I recommend deciding ahead of time which attractions you most want to see and plan your timing accordingly.
  • Accommodations: We stayed at the Murphy Guest House in Bristol. (Check rates here)

Pin It!

Heritage Trail Driving Tour


Disclosures: My visit to Elkhart County was hosted by the Elkhart County Convention and Visitors Bureau Check. Visit their website for further details on the Heritage Trail Driving Tour and other area attractions.
This article contains an affiliate link. If you book a room through the “Check rates here” link above, I will receive a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Thank you for reading Midwest Wanderer. Don’t miss a post. Enter your e-mail address below and click Subscribe, and I’ll notify you whenever I publish another post. Subscription is FREE. After subscribing, be sure to click the link when you get the e-mail asking you to confirm.   – Connie



6 thoughts on “Following the Amish Country Heritage Trail Driving Tour

  • July 3, 2019 at 8:34 am

    This area looks Fabulas hoping to visit sometime
    Thanks for reporting and pictures

    • July 3, 2019 at 11:40 am

      We definitely recommend the Amish Country Heritage Trail!

  • July 7, 2019 at 2:20 am

    I’d like to come to any Amish town, which allows to have photos with Amish people.
    Please give me the phone number then I can contact to be sure that town I really interest to come, thanks so much!

    • July 7, 2019 at 6:41 pm

      The Amish don’t allow pictures of their faces to be taken. They believe that allowing their picture to be taken is an unacceptable act of pride. Please respect their beliefs.

  • August 2, 2019 at 2:18 pm

    Elkhart is so beautiful! It makes me so proud to be able to work and live in such pretty town! Thanks for sharing : )

    • August 3, 2019 at 7:35 am

      You’re welcome! We loved Elkhart and have been back in the area a couple of times since our initial visit.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *